Fears for UK research as EU postdoc applications dry up

Senior scientists say severe shortage of junior scientists from European Union threatens quality of UK research

July 6, 2021
Image of A raft capsizes during a raft race with people falling into the water as a metaphor for Fears for UK research as EU postdoc applications dry up.
Source: Getty

A Brexit-related shortage of applications for junior research posts from the European Union is likely to harm the UK’s ability to win grants from Horizon Europe, senior scientists have warned.

While UK universities have been urged by the country’s main funder, UK Research and Innovation, to apply for grants from the EU’s flagship research scheme, worth at least €95.5 billion (£82 billion) over the next seven years, some research leaders have expressed concerns that dwindling numbers of postdoctoral researchers arriving from the Continent may damage UK laboratories and harm their ability to win funds.

Peter Coveney, director of the Centre for Computational Science at UCL, whose laboratories have led EU-funded projects worth more than €17 million over the past five years, told Times Higher Education that his recent efforts to recruit postdocs had produced not a single application from an EU scientist.

“At least half of applications typically used to come from the EU, but people have shown a lot less interest in recent years – and, in the past two years, it seems the game is up,” said Professor Coveney on the lack of EU applicants.

“When you’re not getting any applicants from the EU it is serious because these countries have education systems that rival our own so we’re missing out on a huge number of very well-educated people,” he said, adding that he had been forced to readvertise some positions on multiple occasions because the right candidate could not always be found.

“If you get a pool of candidates that don’t cut the mustard, you have to try again, which means I’m constantly having to think about this process,” said Professor Coveney, who said that the absence of top-notch junior EU researchers may make it harder to maintain the quality required to win EU grants.

“Everyone in academia is striving to attract the right people for these positions – without them it’s much harder to bring visibility to your work and get the best groups to collaborate with you,” he said, adding that the Horizon system was “designed to bring together teams from different countries and if people are disillusioned with the UK, it’s harder to get them to participate with you”.

Thibaut Jombart, a biometrician at Imperial College London and the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, said that he had also witnessed a dramatic fall in postdoc applications from the EU.

“I’ve sat on a few selection panels in recent years and it was mostly UK candidates, with a lot fewer applying from Europe, which means the average level of applicant is not as good,” said Dr Jombart, who himself arrived in the UK as a postdoc just over a decade ago.

“It’s not certain that I would be appointed now because employers are having to cover various fees for EU postdocs that they previously didn’t,” he said, adding that new bureaucratic hurdles and red tape, including visa fees and additional checks regarding accommodation, might have put him off from applying in the first place.

“I did not go to the US because I would have had to face similar things there,” he said.

Historically, young EU scientists had sought postdoc positions in the UK or US ahead of other countries given their scientific strengths but Brexit and uncertainty over travel caused by the pandemic, which had left many UK-based EU scientists unable to see family for months, was making them consider options closer to home, said Dr Jombart.

“Anything that takes away from that sense that Britain is the best place to do a postdoc is detrimental for UK academia,” he said.


Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please Login or Register to read this article.

Related articles

Reader's comments (4)

Shock! Horror! .... not like it was unpredictable. .... or that the government really cares about post-docs or hotel workers or any area where immigration matters for the labour market. From 2016: https://www.timeshighereducation.com/comment/brexodus-worlds-highly-skilled-have-options-other-uk The other aspect of all this that Brexiters do not understand is that most migrants do not show up at Calais, but at Heathrow, and do so by making a choice among alternatives. While the UK government talks about wanting the “right” type of immigrants (of whom, I suspect, I am one), they do not understand that there is both a supply and a demand for labour. Migrants like me have a choice and the fact that I am wanted does not entail that I will come, or stay. My group advertised three positions before the Brexit vote and got hundreds of applications from all around the world. We ultimately hired an Italian and Romanian, both with overseas PhDs. After losing two junior overseas colleagues, we advertised again after the referendum. We received dramatically fewer applications, and none of them were from the EU, North America or Oceania. We ended up rejecting them all.
The real problem continues to be that academic life is unappealing to UK candidates. This has not changed since I got my PhD in 1990. Most shortlists that I have seen are dominated by non-UK, non-EU candidates of high quality who are often appointed. Given the falling pay in real terms and the uncertainty of the career, I am not surprised that UK students (who now also carry student debt) are rarely interested in PhDs let alone postdoc positions. With the increasing bureaucracy in academic life, I cannot see this changing.
"We received dramatically fewer applications, and none of them were from the EU, North America or Oceania. We ended up rejecting them all." Speaks volumes about the quality of HE in the UK...
Much of U.K. higher education is high quality and produces thousands of excellent graduates, Masters and Doctoral graduates every year. There are plenty of high-quality U.K. candidates, both for post-graduate and post-doctoral posts, but for the past 30 years or so there seems to have been an innate bias against our own homegrown candidates and a politically motivated move towards globalization, and clearly a reliance on funding from the EU. We have plenty of high-quality students here in the U.K., who would make excellent post-docs and academic staff. Just give them a chance.